Bill Gates says it’s ‘not enough to have a kill switch’ for AI: Full interview
- URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AbMxbgIahtE
- Channel: NBC News(Meet the Press,主持人 Kristen Welker)
- Published: 2026-09-27
- Duration: 32:05
- Language: English(NBC 提供字幕,無時間碼)
- Transcript status: 全文已取得(2026-10-29);來源頁面不提供時間碼
逐字稿來源與限制
- 抓取方式:
youtubetotranscript.com(YouTube 字幕全文頁)。本機雲端 IP 直連 YouTube 字幕 API 會被RequestBlocked / Sign in to confirm you're not a bot阻擋,inv.nadeko.net字幕端點回傳 0 bytes,yt-dlp亦被擋,因此無法取得原始 segment 時間碼。 - 字幕為 NBC 上傳的人工字幕(全大寫),本檔保留原始大小寫與斷行,未改寫用詞。
- 來源頁面只給文字、不給時間碼,因此本檔沒有
[MM:SS]標記;引用時請以句意定位,不要標註自估時間。 - 逐字稿未標註發言者;問句為主持人 Kristen Welker,答句為 Bill Gates。少數斷句來自字幕切分,非語意中斷。
Transcript
MR. GATES, WELCOME BACK TO MEET THE PRESS.
GREAT TO BE HERE.
IT’S WONDERFUL TO HAVE YOU.
WE REALLY APPRECIATE YOU TAKING THE TIME.
IT’S A BUSY WEEK.
I WANNA START OFF BY TALKING ABOUT THE INITIATIVE THAT YOU HAVE ANNOUNCED THIS WEEK.
IT, IT AIMS TO ADDRESS ONE OF THE BIGGEST CONCERNS ABOUT AI, WHICH IS THE EQUITY IN THE AI SPACE, THE LANGUAGE BARRIER.
AI MOSTLY BUILT FOR ENGLISH SPEAKERS, AND SO THE GATES FOUNDATION IS PARTNERING.
IF I’M RIGHT, WITH 60 OTHER ORGANIZATIONS, INCLUDING AI COMPANIES TO EXPAND LANGUAGE ACCESSIBILITY, WHY DO YOU THINK THIS IS AN IMPORTANT INITIATIVE?
WHY NOW?
AI MODELS HAVE GOTTEN VERY GOOD AT RECOGNIZING ENGLISH AND ABOUT A DOZEN OTHER MAINSTREAM LANGUAGES, UH, AND SO AS YOU TALK ABOUT YOUR HEALTH, IT’S GONNA ACCURATELY RECORD THAT AND BE ABLE TO HELP YOU IN AFRICAN LANGUAGES, THE ERROR RATE WILL BE ABOUT 10 TIMES HIGHER.
AND SO THAT’S VERY DANGEROUS, YOU KNOW, TAKE UH YORIBA, WHICH IS 3 MILLION PEOPLE.
IN WESTERN AFRICA YOU HAVE 10 TIMES THE ERROR RATE THAT YOU HAVE IN ENGLISH SO IT’S IT’S REALLY NOT USABLE AND YET UH YOU KNOW PURE CAPITALISTIC INCENTIVES WOULD NOT PRIORITIZE THESE LANGUAGES UH AND SO IT WAS AMAZING YOU KNOW WE HOPE TO GET 10 COMPANIES WORKING WITH US WE ENDED UP WITH 60 AND SO WE HAVE A VERY CONCRETE TIMELINE.
UH, TO IMPROVE THE QUALITY, TO BENCHMARK AND THEN SAY, OK, THIS IS GOOD ENOUGH, YOU CAN DO A HEALTH INTERVIEW OR AN EDUCATION SESSION IN THIS LANGUAGE.
WHAT DOES THE TIMELINE LOOK LIKE?
WHAT DOES SUCCESS LOOK LIKE IN YOUR EYES?
WELL, OVER THE FIVE YEARS WE WANT TO TAKE EVERY LANGUAGE THAT A MILLION OR MORE PEOPLE SPEAK, UH, AND HAVE IT.
BE CLOSE TO ENGLISH LANGUAGE QUALITY AND SO YOU COULD SAY THAT A PATIENT UH OR A FARMER OR A STUDENT UH IT MAKES SENSE FOR THEM TO USE THAT AUDIO INTERFACE UH YOU KNOW TALKING ABOUT THEIR CROPS AND THE CHALLENGES THEY FACE UH AND.
UH, SO YOU KNOW THIS IS EXTREMELY WELL DEFINED HOW WE MEASURE THE QUALITY, WHAT DATA WE NEED, AND ALL OF THE MODEL PROVIDERS WILL THEN TAKE THE DATA AND SO THESE CAPABILITIES WILL SHOW UP IN EVERY SINGLE AI MODEL.
HAVE YOU BEEN SURPRISED BY HOW QUICKLY AI HAS BEEN ABLE TO GRASP LANGUAGE CAPABILITIES IN THE FIRST PLACE?
IS THAT ONE OF THE ASPECTS OF IT THAT’S BEEN SURPRISING AS SOMEONE WHO’S WORKED IN THIS SPACE?
WELL, CERTAINLY, WHEN YOU GO BACK TO THE, UH, WHEN CHAT GGPT CAME ALONG, I HAD CHALLENGED THE PEOPLE AT OPENAI UH TO TAKE A TEST, UH, LIKE AN ADVANCED PLACEMENT BIOLOGY TEST, AND, UH, IT WAS ONE OF THE MORE AMAZING DEMOS EVER IN MY LIFE WHEN WE SAW THAT THE YOU KNOW, SO 6 MONTHS BEFORE IT WAS RELEASED, WE SAW HOW GOOD IT WAS AT LANGUAGE.
LANGUAGE IS ACTUALLY A PERFECT APPLICATION FOR THE ARCHITECTURE WE USE HERE AND SO, UH.
YOU KNOW, THE IDEA THAT ALL THE WORLD’S LANGUAGES CAN BE SUPPORTED IS, IS ACTUALLY PRETTY STRAIGHTFORWARD.
AND DOES THAT GIVE YOU OPTIMISM THAT YOU CAN IN FACT MEET THE BENCHMARKS THAT YOU’VE LAID OUT FOR THESE FIVE YEARS?
UM, YEAH, OF ALL THE PROBLEMS IN AI, THIS ONE, IT’S CLEAR WHAT WE NEED TO DO.
IT’S CLEAR HOW WE DO IT.
IT’S CLEAR, YOU KNOW, IT’S OVER 3 BILLION PEOPLE.
UH, WHOSE LANGUAGES ARE CURRENTLY VERY, VERY POORLY REPRESENTED, UH, SO ALMOST HALF THE WORLD, UH, IS GETTING FAR, FAR WORSE QUALITY THAN WE EXPERIENCE.
SO LET’S TALK ABOUT THIS MOMENT IN AI DEVELOPMENT.
YOU ARE ONE OF THE VOICES WHO’S BEEN WARNING ABOUT THE POTENTIAL RISKS.
YOU WROTE IN AUGUST, QUOTE, AI WILL EITHER BE THE GREATEST EQUALIZER EVER INVENTED OR THE WORST SOURCE OF INJUSTICE.
HOW SERIOUS ARE THE RISKS POSED BY AI, DO YOU BELIEVE?
WELL, AI IS NOT JUST A NEW TECHNOLOGY, AND THAT’S WHY PEOPLE WHO SAY, OK, PAST TECHNOLOGIES, THERE WAS ALL THIS WORRY AND, YOU KNOW, BY AND LARGE, IT ALL WORKED OUT, SO MAYBE THIS TIME.
ALL THESE WARNINGS THAT THAT WE HAVE TO SHAPE IT INTENTIONALLY ARE UNNECESSARY.
THIS IS TRULY AN EVOLUTIONARY EVENT, YOU KNOW, WE HAVE CREATED.
AN INTELLIGENT SPECIES THAT IN MANY RESPECTS IS ALREADY SMARTER THAN WE ARE AND OVER THE NEXT SEVERAL YEARS AT KIND OF EXPONENTIALLY IMPROVING LEVEL WILL BE INSANELY SMARTER THAN WE ARE, YOU KNOW, THE ABILITY TO TRANSFER KNOWLEDGE THERE’S NO SORT OF INDIVIDUAL BOUNDARIES LIKE HUMANS HAVING TO EDUCATE EACH OTHER, UH, AND.
SO I CAN’T SAY STRONGLY ENOUGH HOW MUCH SOCIETY, NOT JUST THE COMPANIES, BUT EVERY ACADEMIC THINK TANK VOTER POLICYMAKER NEED TO REALLY ENGAGE ON HOW WE WANNA SHAPE THIS TECHNOLOGY, UM, YOU KNOW, THERE’S NO SUCH THING AS BEING TOO FOCUSED ON, UH, ACCELERATING.
THE GOOD POTENTIAL AND MINIMIZING SOME TRULY HORRIFIC, UH, BAD THINGS THAT, THAT COULD HAPPEN.
YOU SAY SOMETHING THAT IS TRULY NOTEWORTHY THAT IN SOME WAYS AI IS ALREADY SMARTER THAN WE ARE.
IS IT POSSIBLE THAT AI IS ALREADY OUT OF HUMAN CONTROL?
NO, OK.
HUMANS STILL HAVE CONTROL OF AI.
WHAT GIVES YOU CONFIDENCE?
WELL, THE, THE AIS, THEY’RE, THEY’RE NOT RUNNING MILLIONS OF ROBOTS YET, YOU KNOW, SO THEIR ABILITY.
YOU KNOW, WE CAN TURN OFF THE COMPUTER AND THE MOST DANGEROUS THING WE’RE FACING RIGHT NOW IS.
PEOPLE WITH BAD INTENT USING THE AI, YOU KNOW, SO SOMEBODY WHO WANTS TO DEFRAUD AN INDIVIDUAL OR WANTS TO SHUT DOWN THE ELECTRIC NETWORK OR, YOU KNOW, SCRAMBLE BANK ACCOUNTS, THEY ARE NOW EMPOWERED.
HISTORICALLY COUNTRIES YOU KNOW HAD CYBER ATTACK TEAMS AND THEY COULD THINK OF THINGS LIKE BIOTERROR WEAPONS.
NOW SMALL GROUPS WITH AI CAN DO WHAT ONLY THE BIGGEST COUNTRIES COULD DO SO IT’S REALLY THE.
BAD INTENT PLUS AI THAT LOOMS AS A MAJOR THREAT UNLESS GOVERNMENTS INSIST ON.
VARIOUS SAFEGUARDS, UM, YOU KNOW, WE WILL SEE A LOT OF, UH.
BIG NEGATIVE THINGS, UH, BECAUSE WE’RE NOT SAFEGUARDING.
THE BIG HEADLINE IN RECENT WEEKS AS IT RELATES TO AI WAS A WHISTLEBLOWER, AS YOU KNOW, WITHIN THE INDUSTRY SOUNDING THE ALARM, WARNING IN AN ONLINE POST, I’LL READ A PART OF IT.
THE PEOPLE BUILDING AI EARNESTLY BELIEVE THAT IT COULD KILL US ALL BY THE END OF THE DECADE.
DO YOU BELIEVE AI IS POWERFUL ENOUGH TO END ALL OF HUMANITY?
AI IS CERTAINLY POWERFUL ENOUGH TO DRIVE EVENTS, UH, THAT, YOU KNOW, CAUSE A BILLION DEATHS, YOU KNOW, SO EVEN THOUGH IT’S PRETTY HARD TO GET TO 100%, THERE’S NEVER BEEN A WEAPON AS POWERFUL AS THE COMBINATION OF PEOPLE WITH ILL INTENT, UH, USING THE, THE LATEST AI TOOLS AND, AND IT’S GREAT THAT THERE’S THIS DISCUSSION WITH THE INDUSTRY ALMOST AGAINST THEIR INTEREST ADMITTING THESE THINGS.
THE PROBLEM IS THAT THE REST OF THE WORLD IS EITHER DISCOUNTING THIS OR JUST THINKING OF THIS AS A COMPETITION AND UH IT’S VERY SCARY THAT WE DON’T HAVE UH YOU KNOW ALL OF THE THINKERS SAYING HOW DO WE WANT TO SHAPE THIS SO HOW SHOULD PEOPLE BE THINKING ABOUT THIS WARNING FROM THE AI WHISTLEBLOWER WHO SAYS THAT AI IS STRONG ENOUGH TO DESTROY ALL OF HUMANITY?
WHAT SHOULD BE DONE IN THIS MOMENT?
WELL, CERTAINLY, UM.
YOU’VE GOT TO DEAL WITH THE NEAR TERM RISK, WHICH IS THE UH, THAT THESE MODELS ENABLE EXTREMELY STRONG CYBER ATTACKS, EXTREMELY STRONG, UH, DEFRAUDING INDIVIDUALS, AND SO AI INSTEAD OF JUST RUNNING, UH, YOU HAVE TO BUILD THE SAFEGUARDS IN, INCLUDING MONITORING WHERE YOU’RE WATCHING WHAT THE AI IS DOING, YOU KNOW, LAW ENFORCEMENT IS GONNA GET CALLED UP.
YOU KNOW, ON ALL THESE FRAUD EVENTS OR, OR, YOU KNOW, TRANSMISSION SHUTDOWN EVENTS AND THEIR ABILITY TO SEE WHAT’S GOING ON IS GOING TO BE NIL UNLESS THE MONITORING AND SAFEGUARDS ARE BUILT INTO THE AI AND SO THAT IS A SUPER URGENT THING THAT.
IT, IT WON’T SLOW US DOWN THAT MUCH, UM, YOU KNOW, THAT’S ANOTHER DEBATE, UH, SHOULD WE SLOW DOWN OR NOT, BUT DECIDING TO PUT THE SAFEGUARDS AND MONITORING IN, THAT’S A CHOICE WE HAVE AND THE ONLY QUESTION IS DO WE DO THAT BEFORE OR AFTER THERE’S SOME LARGE SCALE, UH, CYBER ATTACKS OR BIOATTACKS.
YOU TAKE ME TO MY NEXT QUESTION, WHICH IS THE DEBATE ABOUT WHAT TO DO.
THERE’S A DEBATE OVER SHOULD THERE BE A KILL SWITCH THAT IS IMPOSED.
OTHERS ARE SUGGESTING A TOTAL PAUSE, AS YOU NOTE ON AI DEVELOPMENT, AND THERE ARE SOME WHO SAY COMPANIES CAN REGULATE THEMSELVES.
HOW DO YOU BELIEVE AI SHOULD BE REGULATED?
WELL, UNFORTUNATELY, MOST DANGEROUS TECHNOLOGIES THE GOVERNMENT UNDERSTANDS BECAUSE THEY FUNDED THE RESEARCH OR THEY’RE AN IMPORTANT CUSTOMER FOR NUCLEAR BOMBS OR ROCKETS OR THINGS LIKE THAT.
AI HAS EMERGED FROM THE PRIVATE SECTOR AND SO THE DEPTH OF UNDERSTANDING OF THESE DANGEROUS THRESHOLDS THAT WERE CROSSED LITERALLY THIS YEAR, UH, BIOATTACK CAPABILITY, CYBER ATTACK CAPABILITY, UH.
AND OTHERS, YOU HAVE SO LITTLE EXPERTISE IN THE GOVERNMENT AND YOU KNOW, BECAUSE IT’S CAST IN THIS NATIONALISTIC, YOU KNOW, US VERSUS THEM TYPE THING, YOU HAVE PEOPLE WHO ARE SAYING, WELL, LET’S JUST GO FULL SPEED AHEAD.
IT’S COMPLETELY IRRESPONSIBLE NOT TO REQUIRE EVERY AI TO HAVE THE SAFEGUARDS AND MONITORING CAPABILITIES AND UH.
IT, IT, IT ONLY UH IS A QUESTION OF DO YOU DO IT NOW?
UH THIS MAY, YOU KNOW, THE EFFORT TO DO THAT WON’T SLOW THINGS DOWN IN A MEANINGFUL WAY.
AFTER ALL, WE’RE ON THIS EXPONENTIAL INCREASE, SO YOU KNOW IT OUGHT TO BE COMMON SENSE TO BUILD THE SAFEGUARDS IN, BUT YOU KNOW WE DON’T YET HAVE, UM, PEOPLE LOOK TO THE US FOR LEADERSHIP ON TOUGH ISSUES USUALLY THAT’S BENIGN LEADERSHIP BRINGING PEOPLE IN, AND THEY’RE A LITTLE CONFUSED WHEN THAT, YOU KNOW, THAT’S NOT TAKING PLACE.
ARE YOU SAYING THAT THE SAFEGUARDS SHOULD BE IMPLEMENTED?
ABSOLUTELY.
IT’S THE WORLD’S MOST OBVIOUS THING.
I MEAN, YOU KNOW, ANTHROPIC REPORTED ON PEOPLE TRYING TO COME IN AND CREATE BIOWEAPONS OR TARGETING CAPABILITIES USING THEIR AI.
THERE’S ALL SORTS OF VERY SOPHISTICATED FRAUD THINGS THAT YOU DON’T NEED, YOU KNOW, PEOPLE IN CAMBODIA TYPING MESSAGES.
THE AI IS 1000 TIMES BETTER THAN THAT, AND SO THESE, THESE NEGATIVES ARE IMMINENT BECAUSE THEY HAVE REALLY STRONG BUSINESS MODELS BEHIND THEM, AND I WANT TO BE REALLY CLEAR, MAKE SURE I UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU MEAN BY SAFEGUARDS.
YOU TALK ABOUT PUTTING MONITORS IN PLACE.
THERE’S ALSO A DISCUSSION ABOUT A KILL SWITCH.
IS A KILL SWITCH POSSIBLE?
IS THAT REALISTIC AT THIS POINT?
THE KILL SWITCHES, THAT’S KIND OF A WEIRD THING.
IT’S NOT ENOUGH TO HAVE A KILL SWITCH.
THEY, THEY, THEY, THEY, THEY’RE NOT YET AT THE POINT WHERE THEY, THEY, THEY AUTONOMOUSLY GRAB COMPUTERS AND, YOU KNOW, CAN’T BE SHUT DOWN.
SO THAT DISCUSSION IS JUST SORT OF SHOWS HOW NON-TECHNICAL VARIOUS PEOPLE ARE, UH, YOU KNOW, I, I WOULD NEVER WANT TO SAY I’M AGAINST THE KILL SWITCH, BUT YOU, YOU DON’T, WHEN YOU, WHEN YOU’RE TRYING TO MODERATE.
THE BAD BEHAVIOR YOU NEED INSIGHT AND RECORDS OF WHAT’S BEING DONE, SO THE KILL SWITCHES ALONE WOULD NOT BE NOT PREVENT THESE TRAGEDIES.
WHAT WOULD PREVENT TRAGEDIES FROM HAPPENING DUE TO AI SPECIFICALLY?
I, I WISH IT WAS EASIER TO DISTINGUISH GOOD INTENT LIKE I WANT TO DESIGN A NEW DRUG FOR A DISEASE VERSUS UH NEGATIVE INTENT WHICH IS I WANT TO DESIGN A TOOL OF BIOTERRORISM.
BECAUSE THOSE ARE SO CLOSE.
WE DO NEED TO MONITOR ANY SOPHISTICATED MODEL AND RECORD.
EXACTLY WHAT’S BEING DONE.
THE UNITED STATES OUGHT TO MAKE SURE THIS IS DONE.
UH, CHINA WILL WANNA DO THIS.
UH, USUALLY PEOPLE EXPECT THE US TO BE VERY CONCRETE ABOUT WHAT THIS LOOKS LIKE, UM, AND YOU’LL HEAR FROM THE INDUSTRY IT’S, IT’S A VERY DOABLE THING.
IT WOULD NOT SLOW THEM DOWN DRAMATICALLY AND SO IT’S THIS, THE SAFEGUARDS AND MONITORING ARE SEPARATE FROM.
WOULD WE BE BETTER OFF SLOWING DOWN?
ANTHROPIC CEO DARIO AMADE RECENTLY CALLED ON AI COMPANIES TO SLOW MODEL DEVELOPMENT TO TRY TO MITIGATE RISKS.
DO YOU THINK SELF-REGULATION IS SUFFICIENT, OR DOES IT NEED TO BE ACCOMPANIED BY LEGISLATION IN WASHINGTON?
SELF-REGULATION IS ENOUGH, SO THERE NEEDS TO BE LEGISLATION PASSED IN WASHINGTON.
ABSOLUTELY.
YOU, YOU NEED.
LAW ENFORCEMENT AND THE POLITICIANS TO GET INTO THE DISCUSSION ABOUT WHAT SAFEGUARDS AND MONITORING LOOK LIKE AND THAT HAS TO BE A REQUIRED THING AND IT WILL BE A LITTLE BIT OF OVERHEAD FOR THE INDUSTRY BUT NOT A DRAMATIC SLOWING OF OF WHAT THEY’RE DOING.
HOW MUCH TIME DO YOU THINK WASHINGTON HAS TO TAKE ACTION BEFORE AI IS ULTIMATELY OUT OF HUMAN’S CONTROL?
WELL, A COMPLETE LOSS OF CONTROL IS VERY DIFFERENT THAN SAYING, UM, YOU KNOW, A BIOWEAPON KILLS 20 MILLION PEOPLE, UH, OR THAT, YOU KNOW, BANK ACCOUNTS GET, GET SCRAMBLED, UH.
YOU KNOW, THE WE CARE ABOUT THINGS WAY SHORT OF THE ULTIMATE DOOMSDAY SCENARIO, AND I’M AFRAID THAT’S KIND OF DISTRACTING PEOPLE.
THERE IS NOT A CURRENT RISK OF THESE AIS GETTING COMPLETELY OUT OF CONTROL.
THE SAME MONITORING THAT WE PUT IN TO AVOID BAD PEOPLE USING AI IS EXACTLY THE MONITORING YOU WANT TO SEE IF THE AI ITSELF IS.
HARMFUL ACTIVITY, BUT THE THING THAT’S URGENT HAS TO DO WITH BAD PEOPLE USING AI, NOT THE AI GOING OFF ON ITS OWN.
IT HAS, YOU KNOW, IN A SENSE I’D SAY IT’S GOOD THAT THESE LOSS OF CONTROL INCIDENTS HAVE GOTTEN PEOPLE FOCUSED ON AI EVEN THOUGH THAT’S NOT THE IMMINENT RISK.
IF YOU WERE TALKING TO LAWMAKERS IN WASHINGTON AND YOU WERE TO GIVE THEM A TIME FRAME.
WHAT WOULD THAT BE FOR THEM TO COME UP WITH REAL CONCRETE LEGISLATION TO ADDRESS THIS, TO PUT THE TYPE OF MONITORS IN PLACE THAT YOU’RE TALKING ABOUT?
UM THIS BECAUSE OF THE LIMITED EXPERTISE IN THE GOVERNMENT.
THERE’LL HAVE TO BE A CONSTRUCT WHERE YOU DRAW ON RESPONSIBLE MEMBERS OF THE INDUSTRY AND HAVE DEBATE THAT OF COURSE THE GOVERNMENT HAS THE ULTIMATE POWER HERE AND RIGHT NOW WE DON’T HAVE A WAY OF DRAWING THAT TOGETHER, YOU KNOW, CERTAINLY ALL COUNTRIES SHOULD WANT THESE SAFEGUARDS IN PLACE SO ANYONE THAT SAYS, WELL, UH, YOU KNOW, CHINA WON’T PUT THESE SAFEGUARDS IN PLACE, I TOTALLY DISAGREE WITH THAT.
YOU KNOW, YOU REALLY, YOU HAVE TO SHOW THAT YOU’RE WILLING TO DO THIS, THEN YOU CAN HAVE A REAL DISCUSSION.
JUST HAVING TWO PEOPLE SAY, HEY, WE HAVE VOLUNTARY REVIEW.
WHAT DO YOU HAVE?
THAT DOESN’T DO ANYTHING.
SO YOU’RE SAYING THERE NEEDS TO BE A GLOBAL RESPONSE, GLOBAL GUARDRAILS PUT IN PLACE IN ORDER FOR THIS TO BE EFFECTIVE.
THAT’S RIGHT, BUT IT.
IT, IT IT’S IT’S COMMON SENSE THAT YOU NEED TO BE ABLE TO SEE WHAT THESE MODELS ARE DOING THEIR ABILITY TO ATTACK NETWORKS, UH, IS, IS PROFOUND AND WE CROSSED THAT THRESHOLD THIS YEAR AND YOU KNOW THE REASON I’M SPEAKING OUT ABOUT THIS AND YOU KNOW UH YOU KNOW INSTEAD OF JUST BEING ABOUT YOU KNOW ERADICATING POLIO OR MALARIA IS BECAUSE I WAS STUNNED.
THAT OUTSIDE THE INDUSTRY AS WE CROSSED THESE THRESHOLDS IT WAS ALMOST LIKE PEOPLE DIDN’T UNDERSTAND THAT IT HAPPENED UH BECAUSE THE VERY STRAIGHTFORWARD SAFEGUARDS UH YOU KNOW WE HAVE VOLUNTARY REVIEW AND THAT THAT IS UH IT’S ACTUALLY PRETTY SCARY WHEN THE PEOPLE WHO ARE WATCHING THIS JUST TO MAKE SURE I’M CLEAR AND THEY’RE CLEAR WHEN YOU SAY CROSS THESE THRESHOLDS YOU MEAN THE FACT THAT SOME AI SYSTEMS HAVE ACTUALLY HACKED INTO OTHER.
NO, THE, WELL, THE THRESHOLD OF MOST CONCERN IS CAN AN AI DESIGN A BIOTERRORISM WEAPON TO KILL MILLIONS OF PEOPLE THIS YEAR?
CAN AN AI FIND FLAWS IN CODE TO ATTACK AND SHUT DOWN ELECTRICITY OR HOSPITALS OR TO SCRAMBLE BANKING SYSTEMS THIS YEAR?
AND SO THOSE CAPABILITIES, IF YOU’RE NOT AVOIDING SOMEBODY BAD.
USING THESE AIS TO DO THOSE THINGS, THAT’S VERY, VERY RISKY.
ON TOP OF THAT, YOU HAVE THE IDEA THAT IN CERTAIN OF THESE SCENARIOS, EVEN THE CREATORS DIDN’T EXPECT THE AI TO BE SO AUTONOMOUS, AND THAT’S THE LONGER TERM WARNING ABOUT NOT ONLY DO WE HAVE TO STOP BAD PEOPLE FROM DOING THINGS, BUT WE HAVE TO STOP.
BY ITSELF FROM GETTING OUT OF CONTROL.
VERY IMPORTANT TO WORK ON THAT, BUT THAT’S NOT THE DANGER WHERE YOU COULD WAKE UP ANY DAY AND SEE A MASSIVE ATTACK THAT WOULD BE A HUMAN DIRECTED MASSIVE ATTACK TODAY.
YOU RECENTLY SAID YOU WANT TO TRY TO TALK TO PRESIDENT TRUMP ABOUT AI.
WHAT WILL YOUR MESSAGE BE TO HIM ABOUT AI?
UM YOU KNOW, I HOPE THAT GIVEN MY LIFE’S WORK IN THE FIELD, MY SAYING HOW UNIQUE AND DIFFERENT THIS IS AND HOW CONCERNED I AM, UH, WILL ADD TO WHAT HE’S HEARING FROM OTHER PEOPLE, UH, AND HE’LL SAY, OK, ONE OF THE GREAT THINGS I CAN DO IS CONVENE PEOPLE TO TALK ABOUT WHAT THESE SAFEGUARDS LOOK LIKE AND.
YOU KNOW, I WON’T BE SAYING WE SHOULD HAVE AN OVERALL PAUSE OR OR SLOWDOWN.
UH, I’LL BE SAYING WE SHOULD IMPOSE A REQUIREMENT ON ALL THE AIS IN THE US AND I EXPECT, YOU KNOW, CHINA DOESN’T WANT BIOTERRORISM.
THEY DON’T WANT, UH, UH, BIG ATTACKS BY NON-GOVERNMENT ACTORS, UM.
YOU KNOW, SO I DON’T THINK THIS WILL AFFECT THE NATION STATE COMPETITION, AS YOU KNOW, PRESIDENT TRUMP RECENTLY POSTED, AI TAKING OVER THE WORLD, DESTROYING HUMANITY, AND ALL OTHER THINGS BAD IS A HOAX.
DO YOU BELIEVE THESE WARNINGS ABOUT AI POSING POTENTIALLY EXISTENTIAL RISK TO HUMANITY IS A HOAX?
NO, IT’S NOT A HOAX AT ALL, BUT JUST BECAUSE HIS INITIAL REACTION WAS THAT HE’LL LISTEN.
HE WANTS TO PROTECT THE US PEOPLE.
MOST PEOPLE DON’T UNDERSTAND WHAT’S GOING ON WITH AI.
THEY’RE NOT USING THE VERY LATEST MODELS, SO WHAT HE SAID IS FINE, BUT I THINK AFTER HE HEARS FROM ME AND OTHER PEOPLE, INCLUDING THAT THIS DOES NOT HANDICAP US IN WHATEVER HE THINKS THE.
UH, NATION STATE RACES, UM, THAT, YOU KNOW, WE WILL COME TO A CONSENSUS AND AS I SAY, THE.
SOME AWFUL EVENTS WOULD INCREASE THE URGENCY, BUT GETTING THE DISCUSSION IN PARALLEL ABOUT SAFEGUARDS WILL HELP US GET THEM IN SOONER THAN LATER.
WE’VE BEEN TALKING A LOT ABOUT CHINA.
PRESIDENT TRUMP’S GOING TO MEET WITH CHINESE PRESIDENT XI JINPING.
WHAT DO YOU THINK IS THE BEST POSSIBLE DEAL THAT THE US AND CHINA CAN REACH AS IT RELATES TO AI?
WELL, THERE’S NOTHING ON THE TABLE TODAY, SO THEY CAN, YOU KNOW, I HOPE THE TEA IS GOOD.
I HOPE THEY SMILE AT EACH OTHER.
THERE’S NO PROPOSAL TODAY TO TAKE THIS IMMINENT DANGER AND.
TO LEARN FROM EACH OTHER AND WORK TOGETHER TO MONITOR AND SAFEGUARD AGAINST THESE DANGERS SO YOU KNOW IT’S GREAT THAT THEY’RE WILLING TO TALK WITH EACH OTHER, BUT THERE’S NO SUBSTANCE TO WHAT CAN BE DONE TO TO HAVE AI CURBED FROM UH NEGATIVE ACTIVITY.
YOU KNOW IT’S INTERESTING BECAUSE DURING THE COLD WAR, THE US AND THE THEN USSR.
WERE ABLE TO COOPERATE ON LIMITATIONS AROUND NUCLEAR WEAPONS DEVELOPMENT, IS THAT A MODEL THAT CAN BE USED RIGHT NOW BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES AND CHINA TO TRY TO REACH AN AGREEMENT ON AI?
YEAH, ABSOLUTELY.
THIS IS MORE DIFFICULT.
UH, THEN THAT WAS MORE DIFFICULT THAN NUCLEAR WEAPONS.
YES, NUCLEAR WEAPONS, ACCESS TO FISSILE MATERIALS, THE ABILITY TO SEE TASKS, THERE WERE THINGS THAT WERE UNIQUE ABOUT IT, YOU KNOW, EVEN THERE WE COULD BE DOING BETTER IN TERMS OF DRAWING CHINA INTO, UH, SOME OF THOSE FRAMEWORKS.
WE’VE LET A LOT OF THAT, UH, STUFF EXPIRE, BUT SINCE WORLD WAR II, THE US SHOULD BE VERY PROUD THAT WHEN THERE HAVE BEEN GLOBAL CHALLENGES WE.
IN A WAY THAT WAS BENIGN, YOU KNOW, WHERE WE HAD FRIENDS AND ALLIES, UH, COMING ALONG WITH US, YOU KNOW, AVIATION SAFETY, OZONE LAYER, UH, NUCLEAR WEAPONS, A LOT OF THINGS WHERE WE WERE PLAYED THE, THE FAIR ACT OR NOT AGGRANDIZING WHATEVER OUR, OUR UNIQUE STRENGTHS WERE, AND AI IS WHEN WE’RE GONNA HAVE TO GO BACK TO THIS, HEY, WE’RE ALL IN HUMANITY IS ALL IN THIS TOGETHER.
BIG PICTURE QUESTIONS ON AI.
I DO WANT TO GIVE YOU THE OPPORTUNITY TO TALK ABOUT THE JEFFREY EPSTEIN MATTER.
OBVIOUSLY YOU TESTIFIED TO CONGRESS ABOUT THAT RELATIONSHIP IN JUNE, AND YOU SAID YOU HAD NO KNOWLEDGE OR PARTICIPATION IN EPSTEIN’S CRIMINAL CONDUCT.
YOU’VE ALSO SAID YOU REGRETTED EVERY MINUTE YOU SPENT WITH JEFFREY EPSTEIN.
WHAT EXACTLY DID YOU REGRET?
I I WAS TOLD BY JEFFREY AFTER I MET HIM THAT HE COULD HELP RAISE BILLIONS OF DOLLARS FOR GLOBAL HEALTH.
UH, YOU KNOW, HE WOULDN’T BE PAID, HE WOULD HAVE NO ROLE, UH, YOU KNOW, THAT PROVED TO BE A COMPLETE DEAD END.
SO, YOU KNOW, IT, MY SPENDING TIME WITH HIM LIKE MANY OTHER PEOPLE KIND OF HELPED HIS REPUTATION, YOU KNOW, THAT’S VERY REGRETTABLE.
UM, YOU KNOW, I REALLY APPRECIATED THE CHANCE TO GO IN FRONT OF THE CONGRESS AND MAKE CLEAR, UH, YOU KNOW, GO THROUGH EVERY MEETING I HAVE WITH THEM, WHICH IS ABOUT, YOU KNOW, 10 MEETINGS OVER A COUPLE OF YEAR PERIOD, YOU KNOW, I NEVER, THERE WERE NEVER ANY, YOU KNOW, WOMEN IN THOSE MEETINGS.
THERE’S NO NOTHING FINANCIALLY.
NEVER WENT TO UH THE ISLAND OR OR ANYTHING LIKE THAT SO YOU KNOW I IF PEOPLE ARE CURIOUS ABOUT THAT, I ENCOURAGE THEM TO READ, YOU KNOW, I, I WAS THERE TO ANSWER ANY QUESTION THAT THAT PEOPLE HAD AND AND YOU DID ACKNOWLEDGE THAT YOU KNEW JEFFREY EPSTEIN WAS A CONVICTED SEX OFFENDER WHEN YOU FOR PART OF THE TIME THAT YOU WORKED WITH HIM.
THE JUSTICE DEPARTMENT SAYS THERE WERE MORE THAN 1000.
SURVIVORS OF HIS CRIMES, WHAT WOULD YOU SAY TO THE SURVIVORS OF JEFFREY EPSTEIN’S CRIMES?
WELL, IN GENERAL, WE EXPECT THE GOVERNMENT IS INVOLVED IN LAW ENFORCEMENT AND THE FACT THAT IN THE FLORIDA CASE THE GOVERNMENT FAILED TO HAVE A PENALTY AND THEY FAILED TO SEE THINGS THAT WERE ONGOING, YOU KNOW, THAT’S AN INCREDIBLE FAILURE OF, OF THE JUSTICE SYSTEM.
COUPLE OF OTHER BIG PICTURE QUESTIONS ON AI IF I COULD, AND WE’RE ALMOST OUT OF TIME.
I, I WANNA TALK ABOUT THE FUTURE AND THE YOUNGER GENERATIONS.
HOW DO YOU THINK AI SHOULD BE USED IN EDUCATION?
IS THERE ANY AGE THAT IS TOO YOUNG TO INTRODUCE AI?
WELL, BECAUSE YOU COULD USE AI AS KIND OF A FRIEND OR COMPANION IN A WAY THAT WOULD BE ALWAYS AGREEING WITH YOU.
THERE IS A HUGE RISK THAT YOU’RE LEARNING HOW TO DEAL WITH UH PEOPLE WHO AREN’T ALWAYS SYCOPHANTIC TOWARDS YOU.
THAT THAT COULD RETARD SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT AND SO CHINA’S BANNED UH THESE KINDS OF USES AND SO WE REALLY HAVE TO DISTINGUISH BETWEEN.
HELPING YOU UNDERSTAND MATH AND PERSONALIZED LEARNING WHERE IT CAN BE MOTIVATIONAL AND AND WORK WITH YOU AT THE RIGHT LEVEL AND AN EMOTIONAL TYPE RELATIONSHIP THAT UH YOU KNOW PROBABLY DOES NOT SERVE YOUR YOUR LONG TERM INTEREST.
HOW DO YOU USE AI IN YOUR EVERYDAY LIFE?
WELL, I’M VERY LUCKY THAT ANYTHING I’M CURIOUS ABOUT GETTING VERY COMPLEX ANALYSIS AND RICH INFORMATION.
UH, THE AI DOES SUCH A FANTASTIC JOB AND, AND, UH, YOU KNOW, IT’S HELPING ME IN THE FOUNDATION WORK, YOU KNOW, WHAT’S THE LATEST ON MALARIA, WHAT’S THE LATEST ON MALNUTRITION, UH, YOU KNOW, IT’S ALLOWING THE GATES FOUNDATION, WHICH WILL SPEND ALL ITS MONEY OVER THE NEXT 19 YEARS, YOU KNOW, WE’VE GOT A BIT OVER 200 BILLION, THAT MONEY WILL BE FAR, FAR BETTER SPENT BECAUSE WE’RE USING AI.
UH, TO GUIDE OUR WORK, ARE THERE ANY WAYS IN WHICH YOU PROFESSIONALLY OR PERSONALLY AVOID AI AND SAY THAT I’M NOT GOING TO, YOU KNOW, CONSULT WITH IT IN THIS INSTANCE?
WELL, I’M NOT USING IT FOR MY PERSONAL RELATIONSHIPS.
I’M NOT LIKE, HEY, DO YOU LIKE ME?
HEY, I’M A A NICE GUY.
SO I, I JUST NEVER WENT DOWN THAT PATH BECAUSE I’M LUCKY IN TERMS OF MY FAMILY, FRIENDS, AND EVERYTHING.
I, I, UH, UH, I DON’T SOCIALIZE WITH THE AI.
IT KNOWS I’M A VERY SERIOUS PERSON.
WELL, LET’S TALK ABOUT YOUR FAMILY.
YOU HAVE 3 KIDS.
YOU HAVE 2 GRANDKIDS.
WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT THESE CHALLENGES THAT THE COUNTRY, THAT THE GLOBAL COMMUNITY IS FACING AS IT RELATES TO AI, WHAT DO YOU HOPE FOR THEIR FUTURE?
WELL, AI WILL HAVE TWO PHASES.
IT’LL HAVE THE PHASE WE’RE ENTERING INTO NOW WHERE.
IT HAS THE POTENTIAL TO SOLVE PROBLEMS, BUT IT HASN’T SOLVED THOSE PROBLEMS, YOU KNOW, YOU’RE STILL RENT IS TOO HIGH, HEALTH IS TOO EXPENSIVE, AND YET IT WILL BE CHANGING THE JOB MARKET AND POTENTIALLY EMPOWERING CRIMINALS, UH, IF WE DON’T HAVE THE RIGHT SAFEGUARDS.
SO YOU HAVE A PERIOD THAT’S PROBABLY 20 YEARS LONG.
WHERE UH YOU HAVE THIS ADJUSTMENT.
ONCE YOU GET THROUGH THAT, UM, THEN A COMBINATION OF HUMANOID ROBOTS AND AIS WILL PROVIDE, YOU KNOW, BUILDING HOUSES, GROWING FOOD, A LOT OF THINGS, YOU KNOW, YOU COULD CALL IT AN AIR OF ABUNDANCE.
THERE’LL BE A CHALLENGE THERE OF MEANING AND HOW YOU SPEND TIME, UH, BUT, UH, THE, YOU WON’T HAVE SHORTAGES THAT, THAT WE WILL TODAY.
YOU KNOW THAT’S FOR THE YOUNGER GENERATION TO FIGURE OUT WHAT THAT LOOKS LIKE MY FOCUS IS CAN WE GET THROUGH THIS PERIOD OF TURMOIL WITHOUT TOO MUCH DAMAGE, YOU KNOW, MAINTAINING EQUITY, YOU KNOW WHAT, WHAT, HOW CAN WE GET THE PERSON WHO WOULD NEVER MEET A DOCTOR IN AFRICA TO HAVE, YOU KNOW, AS GOOD A HEALTH ADVICE AS A RICH PERSON OR THE, THE FARMER IN AFRICA AND SO BRINGING THIS EQUITY LENS TO US, YOU KNOW, THERE ARE CLEAR PROJECTS, YOU KNOW, THEY’RE ALREADY STARTED THAT’S VERY EXCITING.
UH, SO, YOU KNOW TELLING KIDS USE AI IN THE RIGHT WAY, YOU KNOW, PURSUE WHAT YOU’RE CURIOUS ABOUT, THAT ADVICE IS STILL TIMELY, BUT BECAUSE OF THE DRASTIC CHANGES COMING, MY ABILITY TO PREDICT WHAT THE WORLD LOOKS LIKE EVEN IN 10 YEARS IS MUCH LESS NOW THAN DURING MY ENTIRE LIFE.
I MEAN THIS EVOLUTIONARY.
EVENT OF A FOREIGN INTELLIGENCE THAT DIDN’T COME ON SPACESHIPS THAT YOU KNOW CAME IN THESE COMPUTERS IT’S HERE UH AND IT’S IMPROVING AT A UH MIND BLOWING RATE.
BILL GATES, THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH FOR BEING HERE WE REALLY APPRECIATE IT.